Curveballs, Change-ups, and Knuckleballs: Out-of-Left-Field College Interview Questions

College interviews can really throw you a curveball with unexpected questions. As this blog post explores, it's key to prepare for quirky questions about your interests, high school experience, definitions of success, and more. By having talking points ready on your personality, outlook, values, and goals, you can hit these questions out of the park. Preparation is vital for unpredictable questions - read on to learn strategies to convey your authentic self and stand out in your college interviews.

College interviews can feel like the Spanish Inquisition with a barrage of tough questions. While you may expect queries about your background, interests, and goals, some questions may catch you off guard. Here are three surprising questions you may face in an interview and tips to craft thoughtful responses:


What is your favorite book/movie/TV show and why? Plus, what book or movie character do you most identify with and why?

The first question gives the interviewer insight into your personality and interests beyond academics. Share mainstream titles you genuinely enjoy and can discuss deeply. Explain why the themes or characters resonated with you.


The follow-up allows you to make a personal connection with a character whose struggles or personality traits mirror your own. Reference their admirable qualities and how you relate.


If you could change one thing about your high school, what would it be? Additionally, what do you appreciate most about your high school experience?

The first question assess your critical thinking about your environment. Avoid negativity, but share an improvement along with how you'd implement it. Perhaps you'd expand arts programs or upgrade technology.


The second demonstrates your ability to identify positives alongside areas for growth. Share one standout experience, relationship, or opportunity from high school and how it impacted your outlook.


How do you define success? Plus, how will you measure your college success?

Defining success shows your values and motivation. Share your personal philosophy through examples of setting and achieving goals. Define it broadly in terms of learning and growth.


The bonus question requires reflecting on how you'll evaluate success in college - whether it’s through academic achievements, extracurricular involvement, personal growth, or maintaining work-life balance. This shows the school is a good fit.


Preparation is key for unpredictable questions! Focus on conveying your unique personality and outlook throughout your responses.

Share by: