This page is licensed under Creative Commons under Attribution 4.0 International. Anyone can share content from this page, with attribution and link to College MatchPoint requested.
The Only Thing Admissions Officers Can Still See Beyond the Algorithms
If you are worried about how your child can stand out in an era of AI-polished essays and flawless transcripts, you are not alone. Families everywhere are asking how admissions officers will ever see the real student behind the application. The truth is, readers are human, and they are trained to spot what no algorithm can fake. What rises above perfect GPAs and sleek résumés is initiative and impact—the spark that shows a student did more than follow directions. That is what still gets noticed, and that is what breaks through.
Why Algorithms Blur the Picture
Every year, admissions offices face an avalanche of applications. To manage it, they rely on systems that flag GPAs, test scores, class rank, and keywords. AI is creeping into this process too, summarizing résumés and scanning essays.
This levels the playing field in some ways, but it also erases individuality. Perfect transcripts, stacked activity lists, and sleek essays begin to blur together. For families, the risk is clear: your child can look exactly like thousands of others.
So when everything looks polished, admissions officers lean in to find what cannot be automated.
What Breaks Through
It isn’t the student who signed up for every club. It isn’t the essay that reads like it was edited by a committee. What cuts through the noise is initiative and impact—the student who took a step without being told, and who left a mark that others can see.
Admissions readers are human. After dozens of applications in a single sitting, they remember the student who built something real, solved a problem, or took an idea from spark to result.
Two Real-World Examples
At UT Austin: One engineering applicant’s test scores and GPA were strong but unremarkable among thousands of other candidates. What set her apart was that, after a boil-water notice in her town, she designed a low-cost filter in her garage and tested it with neighbors. Her initiative showed she didn’t just study engineering—she practiced it. Her impact was tangible, helping families right in her community.
At Brown: Another applicant noticed that younger multilingual students in his city had no access to affordable math tutoring. On his own, he launched a Saturday math circle at the library. He recruited bilingual volunteers, created translated materials, and grew the program to 40 regular attendees over two years. Brown saw more than grades and leadership titles. They saw initiative in starting something from scratch and impact in how it changed a community.
Neither of these stories could be generated by AI or faked on a résumé. They were lived.
Why This Matters More in an AI World
AI can spit out a five-paragraph essay in seconds. It can draft cover letters or summarize lab results. But it cannot sustain months of late nights, convince friends to join a cause, or adjust strategy after failure.
Admissions officers know this. They are skeptical of too-perfect answers. Increasingly, they look to recommendation letters, project descriptions, and supplemental résumés—places where initiative and impact shine and where algorithms fall flat.
What Parents Can Do
You can’t manufacture initiative or impact for your student, but you can create space for it to grow.
- Encourage depth over breadth. One meaningful pursuit that evolves over time will beat five shallow commitments every time.
- Make room for experimentation. Give your student freedom to try, fail, and try again. Initiative often looks messy at first.
- Help capture the evidence. Notes, photos, project updates—these become the proof points that admissions officers remember.
AI and algorithms are here to stay. But admissions officers remain human, and they want to admit humans. Initiative and impact are the signals that rise above the noise. They show a student not just absorbing knowledge, but using it, shaping it, and sharing it with others.