This page is licensed under Creative Commons under Attribution 4.0 International. Anyone can share content from this page, with attribution and link to College MatchPoint requested.
Beat the Bot: Why Real College Essays Still Matter in the Age of AI
Artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT are becoming a routine part of the college admissions process—for students and, increasingly, for admissions offices themselves. Some colleges, like UNC Chapel Hill, now use AI to score writing quality before a human ever reads an essay. Others, like Duke, have stopped assigning numerical scores to essays entirely, choosing to evaluate them as part of a more holistic review. In this changing landscape, one question keeps coming up for both students and parents: can a chatbot write a better college essay than a student?
The short answer is no. And that’s a good thing.
Why Real Essays Still Matter in an AI World
Students who take the time to reflect, write honestly, and revise with care often produce essays that stand out. The goal is not to sound like a professional writer. It is to sound like yourself. Admissions officers are not looking for a flawless narrative. They are looking for real insight into how a student thinks, what they care about, and how they have grown.
This year confirmed a key truth. The most impactful essays in college applications were not the ones that sounded impressive. They were the ones that felt human.
AI Is a Tool, Not the Author
More students are experimenting with AI tools during the essay writing process. Some use it to overcome writer’s block or to organize early thoughts. In limited ways, this can help students feel less overwhelmed. But the risk is clear. When AI becomes the author, student voice often disappears.
Admissions teams are responding. Duke University, for example, adjusted its essay review process in 2024. Rather than scoring essays numerically, Duke readers now evaluate the content more holistically, with an increased focus on authenticity. Their team made this shift in direct response to concerns about AI-generated content.
Caltech took a strong position as well. “Overuse of AI will diminish your individual, bold, creative identity as a prospective CalTecher,” their admissions office stated in 2024. They added that they are not interested in essays that read like ChatGPT. They want to hear the student.
That theme came up again and again this year. The question is not whether AI can help. It is whether the writing still sounds like the student. If the voice is lost, the connection is lost too.
Authentic Voice Is Still the Gold Standard
The best college essays do not try to sound like they were written by a professional. They sound like a student who has taken the time to reflect on what matters to them. They are specific. They are grounded in lived experience. They are not perfect. They are real.
According to MIT Admissions, “There is no formula for a great essay, and there is no one way to be authentic.” That is the point. The personal statement is not a performance. It is a reflection.
What admissions officers value most is a clear, personal perspective. That often comes from quiet stories: a student who solved a real problem in their community, a moment of failure that sparked growth, a shift in thinking that shaped their goals. These essays do not try to impress. They try to connect. And they work.
What Students Can Do That AI Can’t
There are several things students consistently do better than any chatbot:
Tell a story only they could tell: Students have lived the moments they are writing about. They know the details. They know how it felt. Whether they are writing about a family responsibility, a challenge in school, or a meaningful success, the best essays include lived insight. AI cannot recreate that.
Use a voice that reveals who they are: AI tends to write in a polished, neutral tone. It avoids risk. Students, on the other hand, can write in a way that shows curiosity, vulnerability, humor, or quiet determination. Those are the moments that help admissions officers understand who a student is.
Make original connections: AI repeats patterns. Students are capable of insight. They can reflect on how a particular experience shaped their values. They can connect past challenges to future goals. These connections help the reader see what motivates the student and how they will show up in college.
What This Means for the Class of 2026 and Beyond
AI is not going away. Students will continue to explore it. But this year made one thing clear. The most effective essays still came from students who wrote with intention and reflection. They used their own words. They shared something real.
As more colleges update their review practices in response to AI, the focus on authenticity will only increase. The personal statement remains one of the few spaces where a student can shape how they are understood. And that voice is most powerful when it is unmistakably their own.
So how can families and counselors support this?
Encourage reflection before writing begins: Help students think about moments that mattered to them. Ask what they have learned and how their thinking has changed. The best writing begins with strong reflection.
Shift the focus away from perfection: First drafts should be exploratory. Writing is a process. Students should be encouraged to get ideas down, then revise for clarity and voice. A meaningful essay does not need to be flawless. It needs to be real.
Celebrate voice over polish: The essays that made the biggest impact this year were not always perfect. They were personal, specific, and reflective. They helped admissions officers see the person behind the application.